| Criterion | Grade | Comments | |-----------|-------|----------| | Accuracy | B+ | Most get macrostructure & basic microstructure right. | | Completeness | C+ | Frequently miss run-ons, back matter, sense ordering principles. | | Clarity for beginners | A- | Alphabetical order and definition-numbering are intuitive. | | Depth for linguists | D | Rarely discuss lemma selection, corpus influence, or historical vs. synchronic structure. |
This is what most people come for. A standard dictionary structures definitions in a specific hierarchy: What Is The Structure Of A Standard Dictionary
A complete structural review must discuss: This is what most people come for
Critique
Most introductory reviews ignore back matter entirely, treating it as “extra” rather than integral structure. A strong review would argue that back matter distinguishes a standard dictionary from a minimal word list. or historical vs. synchronic structure. |
Please hold your phone vertically.